How do you like the game?
The most liked upcoming games are being announced as the Gameoneer community’s most anticipated games. Sort games by likes on the games page.
The most liked upcoming games are being announced as the Gameoneer community’s most anticipated games. Sort games by likes on the games page.
You need to sign in to post a review.
4 Reviews
Nightingale blends survival crafting with a stylish Victorian fantasy world, and the result is surprisingly engaging. The Realm Card system is the standout, letting you customize each world you explore in a way that keeps things feeling fresh. Exploration looks great, crafting feels rewarding, and the game really comes alive when played with friends.
It’s not without flaws though. Some realms feel empty, the grind can drag, and the early hours aren’t very clear. Combat can also feel a bit basic. Still, despite rough edges, Nightingale offers a unique and atmospheric twist on the survival genre.
Nightingale is one of those games that took me a while to actually get into. I gave up on it twice before finally pushing through and finishing it – and honestly, I’m glad I did but it was not a smooth start.
The first thing that really threw me off was the art style. It’s super unique, almost dreamlike and while it looks cool, it also makes some of the mechanics and UI harder to read or understand at first. There’s a lot going on in terms of systems and the game doesn’t do the best job of explaining them. One thing that confused me early on was the ore system. You’ll find like 5 different types of ore in one area and you’re thinking, “cool, they must all do different stuff” but then they smelt into pretty much the same few ingots. It made me feel like I was missing something. That’s the kind of stuff that frustrated me and made me quit more than once.
But once I finally powered through to the endgame, things changed. This is where the game actually starts to shine. You start grinding dungeons for better and better materials, which let you craft stronger gear. That better gear lets you take on harder dungeons and that’s the loop. It’s actually super satisfying once you get into it but the game doesn’t make that clear early on. You either have to figure it out yourself or watch some long youtube breakdowns from people who already put 100 hours in.
I’m not personally a huge fan of the art style but it’s definitely unique and I know some people will love it. It grew on me a bit but not my favorite.
TL;DR: rough start, confusing systems but a surprisingly solid endgame if you stick with it.
If you’re hoping for a fae-themed adventure, this is not it.
If you’re looking for a survival game, this is actually still not it — your tech tree is locked by story progress.
The game direction took a sharp turn during the v0.5 RR overhaul and afterward they just finally took players to Nightingale where there’s basically no story and the tasks you do to progress to the final boss fight that ends the story is meaningless.
The finale of the game is also a huge letdown. Basically nothing happens other than you fight a boss.
So it’s slightly better than a survival game in that there’s an attempt at a story.
But it’s way worse than an RPG.
And after you’re done, there’s just grind if you like: build a huge house or fight the same bosses over and over again in harder modes.
That said, the game is finally stable enough to be playable without problems, although optimization might be a bit rough.
I am really enjoying the game a lot. It has a not-so-fast gameplay system, meaning the evolution of your character and your survival is neither fast nor easy. The game draws its essence from various games. The food system reminds me of Valheim. Depending on what you eat, you will have more life or more energy for your character, and it lasts for a certain period.
The construction system reminds me of ARK and other games where you first place the blueprint and then gradually build. Although with some improvements, like if you input all the materials, it builds everything at once. It has a dungeon system with very entertaining bosses that add an extra touch of risk and adventure.
I am aware that it’s an Early Access game, so I am quite optimistic that we will see improvements in this game over time.